Face it, traditional advertising doesn't have the zing it used to. Customers today are exposed to more than 5,000 brand messages a day, and they've become quite good at tuning out the vast majority of them. But this is where brand advocacy comes to be a total game-changer.
And when your own customers are out there telling their friends, family and co-workers how much they love your brand, that's marketing gold that just can't be bought. A lot of numbers out there, but according to Nielsen's Global Trust in Advertising report, 92% of consumers trust peer recommendations over advertising. That's a massive distinction that shrewd marketers are capitalizing on through programmatic brand advocacy.
Brand advocacy is the highest form of customer relationship marketing, happy clients volunteering to be the voice for your business. It's different from sponsored influencer relationships or a typical ad buy, it's the result of great customer experiences that naturally lead to sharing.
The core idea is so simple and yet seems to be very difficult: provide experiences so fabulous that your customers just can't help but tell others about them. This genuine excitement results in a domino effect that allows your marketing range to spread a lot further than any pay to play potential.
As Dr. Philip Kotler, marketing professor at Northwestern University and arguably the father of modern marketing points out:
i"The most powerful marketing has always been word-of-mouth. Today, word-of-mouth does not need to be traditional, spoken word."
— Dr. Philip Kotler, Professor of Marketing at Northwestern University
This is something that explains why the brand advocacy programs are now vital for the business sustainability.
The added value of advocacy is its authenticity. So when a customer raves about your brand, they are in a sense staking their personal reputation on your company. This leap-of-faith transfer of trust endows you with credibility that your money can't buy you with traditional advertising methods.
The digital revolution has now raised the potential of advocacy to the nth degree. Instead, personal recommendations have become broadcasts across social media, review sites and messaging apps, turning friendly suggestions or new product obsessions into signals that can reach hundreds or thousands of people in an instant.
Understanding the psychology behind customer advocacy behavior reveals fascinating truths about brand advocacy as researched in consumer psychology. The basis stands on a few basic tenets that smart marketers can apply in order to create better advocacy programs.
There's the social proof phenomenon, for one, people always tend to rely on other people's behaviors and opinions when they're making their own decisions, particularly in situations of extreme uncertainty. According to Edelman's Trust study, 74% of respondents consider word-of-mouth a trigger purchasing decision.
Advocacy behavior is likewise motivated by the reciprocity principle to a large extent. If customers have a true sense they matter as individuals to a brand, they are more likely to naturally want to express an experience that has positively shaped the way they represent themselves. This builds the positive feedback cycles where outstanding customer experiences create advocates, who bring in new customers that can become advocates themselves.
Jay Baer, founder of Convince & Convert, describes it well:
i"Customer service is the new marketing. Every encounter is a chance to make an advocate or a detractor."
— Jay Baer, Founder of Convince & Convert
This perspective demonstrates why you need to get the customer experience optimization right before rolling out an advocacy program.
Trust is so important in the success of advocacy. According to a Harvard Business Review study, boosting customer retention rates by 5% can raise profits by 25% to 95%, illustrating the exponential worth of creating advocate relationships for the long term.
The emotional attachment cannot be underestimated either. Consumers who are emotionally connected with a brand are worth more than twice as much as highly satisfied customers, studies show. Such an affect bonding is the driving force behind the voluntary advocacy behavior.
Here's how company 101-level companies across the US used brand advocacy to accomplish amazing things. These are case studies on grassroot, firsthand testimony of the potential and the actual effect of a well proposed advocacy.
Tesla's approach to growth strategy is completely inverting the traditional marketing and advertising strategy within the automotive industry. The company runs on what is essentially a $0 advertising budget and continues to experience limitless growth through methodical advocacy stewardship.
Their model is based on the delivery of products so awesome that customers can't help but turn into zealous fans. In its first iteration, Tesla's customer referral program resulted in 40x ROI with some of its top advocates contributing to over $44 million worth of sales from their personal networks.
The genius of Tesla was to trade the reward on Tesla's value, it was their all along. Instead of merely trying to offset the blow with cash incentives, they offered experiences you couldn't buy, like:
This formed an exclusive club of enthusiastic brand advocates.
The results tell you everything about how effective advocacy is. Tesla maintains a 96-97 Net Promoter Score, the best among car companies. Based on the consumer satisfaction survey, 99% of Model 3 owners would recommend Tesla to friends and family.
Starbucks has uniquely leveraged employee advocacy internally, referring to its employees as "partners" and not its staff. This cultural mentality produces internal brand champions who ACTUALLY believe in the brand and spread the branding to their personal networks.
This is where the company's employee advocacy approach deviates from the generic script. They share organically because they actually believe in what the company is doing and why.
The evidence shows the strength of genuine advocacy efforts:
Employee amplification happens organically, as employee content seems more genuine and less 'salesy' than corporate content.
Patagonia has created one of the most genuine advocacy programs by connecting brand values with customer attitudes about environmental stewardship. They focus on shared mission, not just product quality.
The company's notoriously controversial "Don't Buy This Jacket" campaign ultimately increased sales by 30% to $543 million, proving that true advocacy can break the traditional marketing mold. This counterintuitive strategy, Investopedia's analysis finds, deepened customer relations.
The Patagonia strategy of advocacy is about being transparent and actually having skin in the game for the environment. With projects such as Worn Wear and its 1% for the Planet program, they have contributed more than $140 million to environmental nonprofits since 1985. This gives real reasons for customers to evangelize beyond product satisfaction.
The sustainability-centric marketing approach has developed a cult-like following among environmentally driven consumers who wear their choice as a badge of identity and values.
Brand advocate programs can dramatically reduce the cost of customer acquisition as their references are organic and will cost a business in terms of marketing to achieve. Studies have found that the cost to acquire a new customer is on average 62% lower through referred sales versus other sales channels.
Cost efficiencies are also realised beyond mere acquisition metrics. Referred customers have:
This drives virtuous circles of growth and compounding organic growth over time.
Boosting customer retention rates by just 5% can lead to a 25% to 95% increase in profits, emphasizing the cumulative effects of advocacy powered customer acquisition strategies.
This cost effectiveness makes advocacy programs especially interesting for companies in competitive markets with the relentless increases in traditional advertising costs coupled with the reduced effectiveness that comes from consumer ad fatigue and increased competition for consumer attention.
Advocacy programs create real brand credibility, something traditional advertising can't compete with. Hence, when your customers voluntarily vouch for your brand, they co-sign you with their personal reputation that trust can't be bought from money through traditional marketing medium.
This is where this kind of credibility really makes its stand out, and this is especially important in oversaturated markets where the clueless consumer drowns in pondering decision. PwC's Trust Survey revealed that 90% of B2B and B2C executives feel that customers trust their organisations, but just 30% of consumers agree, a 60 percentage point difference in trust perception.
The credibility of advocacy-derived recommendations serves as a mediator for this trust disconnect. Peer recommendations are naturally influential because they derive from parties not with a vested financial interest in selling one brand over another, so they are far more convincing than commercial advertising.
When your brand is trusted, there's a compounding benefit at each stage of the customer journey, all the way from initial awareness through consideration and to post-purchase satisfaction, creating more resilient customer relationships and better conversion rates overall.
Brand Advocates are significantly more valuable than the average customers across the board. Customer advocacy studies indicate that advocates spend up to 5 times more than the average customer because they form a deeper, more emotional connection and higher satisfaction level with brands.
There's a multiplier effect when you tie advocacy to lifetime value that is felt far beyond single transactions. Not only do advocates spend more themselves, but they also refer friends to the company, expanding total customer value exponentially through their personal networks.
According to the customer research pro Jay Baer:
i"Customer retention is the new customer acquisition. The firms of the 2020s that win will be the ones that convert customers into volunteer marketing armies."
— Jay Baer, Founder of Convince & Convert
It's no wonder, then, that advocacy-driven strategies tend to be much more effective than traditional acquisition strategies.
Then of course there's the loyalty factor. Average advocates tend to retain 90 percent higher than non-advocates, lowering churn costs, and driving what is effectively recurring revenue, providing a stable foundation for overall sustainable business growth.
Advocacy-based programs amplify a brand's reach to audience they can not target via traditional advertising channels but who are part of potential buyers' networks. Research on employee advocacy found that when content is shared via employees vs. official brand channels, engagement increases by 8 times.
This virality happens organically as content generated by advocates is perceived to be more genuine and specific to their own networks. It does not have the same feeling of sales pitch, and it increases the return and conversion rate vastly.
It offers the possibility of exponential growth for advocacy efforts. Each happy customer can spread the word to many potential customers through their network, who can then broaden their own network, with cascading effects that amplify the marketing effect well beyond the effort put in.
According to word-of-mouth marketing statistics, 68% of customers are willing to talk about a brand if they had something positive to say, making it a natural opportunity for brands that provide amazing experience after amazing experience.
And, unlike advertising campaigns which competitors can copy or outspend, real customer advocacy delivers persistently sustainable competitive advantages, it is very hard to copy. Effective advocacy requires the relationships and trust not bought or easily replicated by old-fashioned marketing gimmicks.
Authentic advocacy must be built on the sustained delivery of amazing experiences over time, creating barriers to the entry for emerging competitors that will threaten our market position and customer relationships. This depth of relationship is very important in more mature markets where the differences may be small in the products.
The time needed to develop real advocacy relationships is also a source of switching costs for customers who've invested emotional capital in brand relationships. This emotional stickiness translates to advocates being far less likely to churn to competitive solutions, even in the face of price reduction or superior functionality.
Of course, the best customers for firms with robust advocacy programs are those who zealously defend the brand against competitors, a form of organic protection that traditional advertising does not provide.
Active advocates are precious sources of market feedback, they are genuinely interested in your brand's success, and they are rooting for your steady progress. Such a feedback loop allows companies to recognize improvement opportunities, to monitor and comprehend changing customer demands, and to provide offerings that can truly best adapt to dynamic market conditions.
Advocates are:
The quality of feedback from advocates is often unmatched since it's sourced from customers that cherish the brand, and who wants to see it grow. This presents opportunities for collaborated product development and service enhancement that enhance customer relationship and business efficiency.
Customer advocacy tracking systems allow firms to spot trends and new insights faster than their competition following traditional market research approaches, providing you with strategic advantages in fast-moving markets.
Brands with cultures of strong brand advocacy often see higher levels of employee engagement, for people are proud to be able to say they work for respected, customer-loved brands. This leads to positive loops of employee satisfaction supporting advocacy, which in turn results in enhanced employee pride and engagement.
The interplay of employee and customer advocacy will prompt the strength of an organization to facilitate long-term business success, above and beyond the realm of traditional marketing measures. Staff members, who witness customers really falling in love with the brand, get more involved in offering great experiences that fuel advocacy cycles.
Employee advocacy stats indicate that engaged employees make companies:
This internal and external advocacy alignment builds cultural power that parallels recruiting and results in organizations that are hardier in tough times and more agile at managing growth in expansionary times.
Effective advocacy programs start by consistently providing great customer experiences that naturally elicit sharing behaviour. You just cannot make advocacy out of average experiences, no amount of fancy structuring of your program, and clever systems of incentives will ever produce it.
Shep Hyken, customer service expert and writer, puts it this way:
i"Good customer service is not just about solving problems. It's the ones that you could never forget and you wanted to tell your friends about."
— Shep Hyken, Customer Service Expert and Author
This revelation is why customer experience optimization comes before advocacy program launch.
Zero in on where customer touchpoints that drive advocacy can be optimized. Whether it's:
All these interactions contribute to the customer's overall satisfaction.
Do an analysis of your customer journey and pinpoint friction points, delight opportunities, and the moments when people are bound to naturally engage in advocacy behavior when they're happiest with your product or service.
Leverage data-focused methods to target customers who are likely inclined to be effective advocates by satisfaction, levels of engagement, and influence in their relevant circles. The Net Promoter Score questionnaire can help single out promoters (scored 9-10) who will make good advocates.
Segment customer-related indicators such as:
Search for those customers who are already showing advocacy behaviours naturally.
Develop strategic approaches to cultivate known advocates with privileged access, personalized communication plans, and recognition programs that celebrate their social endorsement and support for your brand success.
The point is to deliver value to advocates first and then to request promotional efforts. That could be early product usage, premium content, speaking or networking opportunities, or even access to company leadership so that your customers can benefit meaningfully.
Compelling advocacy programs are all about giving members something of value, not just asking for promotion. It's this value-first mentality that leads to stronger relationships and more meaningful advocacy in the long run.
Think about what your ambassadors are really after, it could be:
Studies on the customer advocacy strategy suggest that advocates are driven more by recognition than monetary rewards.
Ann Handley, Marketing Pro, said it best:
i"The best marketing doesn't feel like marketing. If you really value the success of your customers, they will become your strongest advocates without any effort."
— Ann Handley, Chief Content Officer at MarketingProfs
This customer first focus builds real advocacy relationships.
Create graduated value propositions for varying advocate personas and preferable types of engagement. Others would prefer shout-outs, or individual access to executives, or exclusivity in a community.
Make advocating easy by creating content your member can share, simplified referral flows, and guidance on how and when to share. The easier you make it for customers to participate in your advocacy, the more likely they'll get involved on a regular basis.
Create supporters to ambassador content libraries with a mix of:
That advocates can simply input their unique information, personalize, and share to their personal networks with brand uniformity.
Establish systems through technology to capture what advocates are doing, decisions are made, how they are impacting, and what is done with that data. Management tools for advocacy programs so that you can automate everything you can and keep everything as personal as you can.
Establish clear communication guidelines that outlines what make shared contexts appropriate, messaging limits, and methods for maintaining an authentic voice when promoting your brand.
Set up a full suite of KPIs to measure the success of your advocacy program such as:
Word of mouth marketing generates $6.50 in word of mouth value for every $1 invested when properly measured.
Monitor quantitative results (e.g., referrals generated, revenue attributed, reach achieved) and qualitative indicators (e.g., advocacy quality, message authenticity, relationship strength) simultaneously to get a complete view of program effectiveness.
Ongoing performance analysis to determine what's working, and what can be optimizing, will help programs adapt to changing customer behavior and competitive dynamics. Implement A/B testing on various approaches and incentive structures.
Show advocates their performance and how they are making a difference by sharing results and showing the value of their participation in the program by contributing to brand growth and campaign success.
At the heart of brand advocacy is developing authentic promotion from happy customers that willingly advocate for your brand because of real positive interactions they have had with your products or services. Very simply put, influencer marketing is the practice of working with people with influence, popularity, or, in this case through particular social media channels, a lot of followers, and paying that person to partner with you, to promote your product.
The three major distinctions are the motive, the authentic feeling, and the length of the relationship:
While both can be powerful parts of an overall marketing program, advocacy usually registers at a higher-level of trust because it nearly always reflects genuine experience and not a paid plug.
Trust studies continually demonstrate: recommendations from peers are up to 50 times more trustworthy than branded advertising (Nielsen). Advocacy programs play a crucial role in building true brand trust over time as consumers naturally view word of mouth as approximately 50 times more trustworthy than branded advertising.
For successful brand advocacy, multiple metrics are necessary to convey different elements of program effectiveness. Key metrics to track include:
Sophisticated measurement techniques include:
Measure program ROI with the following formula: (Referral Revenue + Saved Marketing Costs + Brand Created Value) ÷ Total Program Investment. Successful advocacy programs can see ROI anywhere between 300% to over 1000%, depending on execution and industry.
Leverage cohort analysis to observe advocate behavior over time by evaluating individual advocate value as well as general program performance trends. This aids in identifying program optimization opportunities and demonstrating program value to organization stakeholders over the long term.
Effective brand advocacy programs generally take 6-12 months to begin reaching a tipping point, but can take 18-24 months to fully mature, based on starting base-line customer satisfaction, level of program complexity, and organization commitment to execution.
First stages include:
Companies with significant existing customer relationships could be seeing "Early Wins" in 90 days.
Some businesses that desperately need to enhance customer experience will need a lengthy period of development before embarking into advocacy programs. It also varies depending on the industry as B2B businesses' decision-making processes and sales cycles are typically longer.
Patience and steady performance are required here because advocacy relationships take time to generate good faith and participation that will drive ongoing behaviors promoting offering from satisfied customers.
Brand advocate programs are relevant to almost any industry, however some industries find them to be especially effective because of the intrinsic nature of the industry and the way customers behave:
High-success industries:
Success factor isn't industry type, but a company's capacity to provide such outstanding experiences that advocacy is inspired as a natural expression of satisfaction. Companies in heavily regulated fields may be required to modify program structures to meet industry-specific promotional rules.
Success also relies on:
Criticisms by allies should be treated as useful feedback, not program flaws to be managed. Advocates sharing constructive criticism are concerned about the success of your brand and want to help improve, not tarnish, it.
Best practices for handling negative feedback:
Many champions become even more loyal when they see brands deal with concerns constructively and take on board recommended enhancements.
Create formalized feedback loops that make it easy for advocates to point out deficiencies in private, before they take their concerns public. This provides you with openings to resolve problems before they become bigger issues impacting your relationships with important brand ambassadors.
Start small, 10-25 vocal advocates are better than trying to stand up big programs from the jump. This size is a reasonable scope in which to iterate on processes, experiment with approaches, and refine program components before scaling to broader groups of participants.
Quality over quantity approach:
Ramp up incrementally to the ability of the program to perform well and to the capacity of the organization to build high-quality relationships with participants. Quick growth can water down the utility of a program and lose the kind of one-on-one focus that can help advocacy programs succeed.
Small businesses are quite often in the enviable position to excel in creating advocacy programs because of advantages that large businesses can't easily match:
Small business advantages:
These are often more important to advocates than the scale of programs or the size of financial incentives.
Begin with great customer service and relationships, rather than fancy technology platforms or intricate incentive programs. Some of the most effective small business advocacy programs work with basic tools, but strong personal relationships.
Develop experiences that are unique to your company, such as features based on local ties and industry knowledge. Small businesses may offer touchpoints and experiences that larger rivals can't replicate based on their size and organizational design.
Start by assessing overall customer satisfaction, current advocacy behaviors, system preparedness for the launch of a systematic advocacy program. This baseline assessment is useful for realistic goal setting and program design.
You also want to make sure you keep it smart, meaning the goals should tie back into the big picture like "increase customer referrals by 25% in six months" vs. "improve brand advocacy."
Estimate the baseline of current advocacy by:
This sets benchmarks for program efficacy and ROI to be measured against over time.
Build program structure including participant eligibility, engagement activities, value exchange and success metrics helps your program align with your customer profile and business model.
Leverage data-driven methods to zero in on potential fans, assessing:
Focus on customers who are happy and influential in the various networks that are relevant.
Audit customer behavior data such as review-writing, social sharing, referral-making and community action to find out who are already advocates by nature, that is to say, who already acts organically as advocates.
Build custom outreach strategies that convey the clear value of advocacy participation and discuss benefits of the advocates rather than what you're asking them to do.
Design targeted recruiting strategies based on:
To increase participation rates and program impact at the program launch and beyond.
Develop structured user engagement strategies to add continuous value for advocacy creation. This encompasses:
Develop protocols for onboarding new advocates so they have an understanding of:
Create libraries of reusable content, sharing widgets and communication templates that easily allow users to take action on discovery with coherent brand message.
Create a cadence of communications, from program updates to sharing success stories to gathering feedback, that keeps ambassadors engaged but doesn't overload overwhelmed advocates with too many asks.
Leverage performance data to understand what works in a program and where there are opportunities to optimize through ongoing analysis of:
Systematically A/B test various engagement strategies, incentive designs & communication styles to optimize program effectiveness and satisfaction of participants.
Grow program incrementally in response to performance outcomes and the capacity of the organization to develop quality relationships with larger numbers of participants without diluting the program.
Build advanced measurement capabilities such as:
To showcase program ROI and guide future strategic decision making.
Brand advocates are much more than simply another marketing tool, they represent a fundamental business concept, a strategic business approach in which companies establish competitive superiority by building loyal customer relationships and developing the ability to generate growth within and up the tiers of the marketplace.
Now for these organizations, there's no question the data clearly supports investment in an advocacy program if you're serious about long-term growth. Through in-depth customer engagement studies, fully engaged customers deliver a 23% premium in terms of share of wallet, profitability, revenue, and relationship growth while being associated with 11% higher NPS.
But, you can't fake brand advocacy, and you can't bribe people into being authentic if you're not willing to live up to them in other ways. It needs the real commitment to customer value creation, to making the relationships in a systematic way and to sustainable business development, not to immediate promotional action.
And, as Philip Kotler points out:
i"The most powerful advertising is a satisfied customer."
— Philip Kotler, Professor of Marketing at Northwestern University
This universal truth is never more true than in our digital economy, where customers have more way to blast out their voices than ever through digital amplification.
i"In today's hyper-connected marketplace, brand advocacy isn't just a nice-to-have, it's the cornerstone of sustainable digital growth. After two decades in this industry, I've witnessed companies transform from struggling startups to market leaders simply by turning their satisfied customers into passionate evangelists. The brands that master this art don't just survive, they dominate their competition."
— Tessar Napitupulu, CEO of Arfadia & Digital Marketing Expert
The businesses that operationalize a customer-centered approach to being advocated for will be the ones to create the most economic resilience, more robust defensible positions, and growing engines of expansion that become more valuable with the passage of time. What you call brand advocacy is far from just effective marketing, it's the construction of strategic business assets that provide value for the organization, the advocate and the customer all at the same time.
Back to basics: the future is that the power of organisations to turn merely happy customers into evangelical fans who then spread the word organically from personal experience.
We use cookies to ensure the website runs optimally and to help us understand how you use our services. You can choose which categories to allow. Read our Privacy Policy.
Required for basic website functionality. Cannot be disabled.
Help us understand how visitors interact with the website. Data used anonymously.
Used to display relevant ads and measure campaign effectiveness.
Enables live chat, social media integrations, and language preferences.