What is Holistic Marketing? Complete Strategy Guide

Holistic marketing is an all-inclusive business strategy that draws in all business management departments, and applies marketing techniques to enable organizations to achieve strong, broad-based customer needs. Instead of the classic marketing silos, this new approach acknowledges that "everything does make a difference" when it comes to marketing success.
Strategy and Planning Integrated Marketing Communications (IMC)Marketing AutomationCustomer Relationship Management (CRM)Omnichannel Marketing
What is Holistic Marketing? Complete Strategy Guide - Arfadia

Picture this: a customer sees your Facebook ad, visits your website, signs up for your emails, contacts your customer service team, and then buys in your store. In most organizations, those touchpoints aren't joined up. The messages conflict, the experiences vary, and the information doesn't flow. That's where holistic marketing comes in.

At Arfadia, we've helped hundreds of companies and organizations rethink their marketing after discovering that siloed marketing, advertising, or design approaches weren't working. The result is typically measurable revenue growth and better customer satisfaction within the first year.


The Transition from Traditional Approaches to Holistic Marketing Strategies

Marketing has changed a lot over the past century. It moved from the production-focused thinking of the early 1900s, through the sales era, to the customer-focused marketing concept that took hold in the 1950s, and now to the integration of departments and customer focus we see in modern businesses.

This evolution hasn't been random. It's a direct response to shifting consumer behavior and advances in technology. In the 1990s, relationship marketing theory and research gained ground as businesses recognized the value of long-term customer relationships. Yet even that wasn't enough for today's hyperconnected world.

The digital transformation required something broader. Traditional marketing functions worked like freelancers, each finishing its own part without seeing the whole. Marketing departments were siloed from sales, customer service used different messaging from advertising, and social media teams seldom synced up with email marketers. The result? Confused customers and wasted resources.

Philip Kotler's analysis of holistic marketing captured the concept well: it recognizes that "everything matters" in marketing, including customers, employees, other companies, competitors, and society as a whole. But this is more than academic theory. It's a practical framework that delivers business results across sectors.

Consistency alone pays off. Organizations in Demand Metric's 2016 study with Lucidpress estimated average revenue growth of 23% from always presenting their brand consistently, and integration across channels adds to that by removing duplicated work and letting channels reinforce one another.


The Four Pillars of Holistic Marketing Explained

Internal Marketing: How Your Entire Organization Can Own Your Entire Message

Internal marketing is the engine that powers everything else. We've found that you can't consistently deliver great customer experiences if your own team isn't aligned and engaged. Internal marketing treats employees as the first customers and helps them understand and live your brand values.

This goes far beyond occasional team meetings or company newsletters. The most effective internal marketing builds a culture where every employee is a brand ambassador. We help our clients make these programs part of their culture through training, open communication, and recognition programs that encourage the behaviors they want.

When your accounting team understands its impact on customer happiness, or warehouse staff see their role in the brand experience, the effect is powerful. The data backs this up: according to Gallup's research on employee engagement, business units with highly engaged employees are 23% more profitable and see lower turnover.

Even more important for marketing results, engaged employees deliver the authentic, consistent experiences today's customers expect. We've seen this first-hand at Arfadia in our work with retailers: stores with motivated staff score higher on customer satisfaction.

Integrated Marketing: Creating Seamless Experiences

Integrated marketing is the tactical core of holistic marketing. It ensures that every point where a customer interacts with your business, from your website and social media to your email campaigns and in-store experience, delivers coherent, compelling messages that amplify one another.

We've seen countless businesses treat each marketing channel as its own empire. The Facebook team runs one type of campaign and email marketing runs another. Paid ads push one message while content marketing covers unrelated topics. This fragmentation confuses consumers and weakens the brand.

Real integration is about more than putting the same logo everywhere. It requires synchronized messaging, coordinated campaign timing, and connected data systems that share intelligence across channels. In the same Demand Metric and Lucidpress research, organizations estimated revenue increases as high as 23% from presenting their brand consistently.

Disney is a well-known example of this kind of integration. Whether you watch a Marvel film, visit a theme park, browse its streaming service, or buy its products, each touchpoint is designed to feel like part of the same story. That's integrated marketing in action.

Recent research indicates from McKinsey on performance branding found that companies combining brand and performance marketing across the full funnel report marketing efficiency gains of up to 30% and incremental top-line growth of up to 10%, without raising their marketing budgets.

Relationship Marketing: Building Lasting Connections

It's not merely transactional; it's about relationships and value built over years or decades. Relationship marketing means building relationships with everyone involved in your business: customers, employees, partners, suppliers, and the community.

We emphasize relationship marketing partly because the math is so persuasive.

i

"Holistic marketing represents the evolution of marketing from a tactical function to a strategic business philosophy. When organizations truly embrace this integrated approach, they don't just improve their marketing ROI, they fundamentally transform how they create value for customers across every interaction."

Tessar Napitupulu, Founder and CEO of Arfadia

You'll often see the estimate that It costs five to seven times more to acquire new customers than to keep existing ones. Bain's Fred Reichheld is the source most often cited for the claim that increasing customer retention by just 5% can boost profits by 25% to 95%; the linked Bain brief gives a specific example: in financial services, a 5% increase in customer retention produces more than a 25% increase in profit.

These aren't just numbers; they're real opportunities for sustainable growth that we help our clients pursue every day.

Relationship marketing is a mindset. Instead of asking, "How can we sell more product?" we help clients ask, "How can we create more value for customers?" That shift leads to ideas ranging from personalized experiences and proactive customer service to loyalty programs that truly reward loyalty, not just more frequent purchases.

Performance and Socially Responsible Marketing: Creating Shared Value

The fourth pillar surprises classic marketers, but it's becoming more important to running a successful business. Kotler calls this component performance marketing: understanding the financial returns of marketing and its wider impact on society and the environment. This isn't about greenwashing or token charitable donations; it's about real commitment to positive change.

Consumers, especially younger ones, increasingly buy from brands whose values match their own. A figure often attributed to Edelman says 76% of consumers will choose a brand they feel connected with over competitors, though we couldn't find it in Edelman's published reports. What Edelman's 2019 brand trust research does show is that trust has become a deciding purchase factor, and that connection often comes from shared values around sustainability, social justice, or community support.

We help clients design programs that grow naturally out of their business. That could mean sustainable sourcing and fair labor practices, community investment, or environmental protection. The key is authenticity: consumers can spot insincere "purpose-washing" from miles away.


Real-Life Success Stories That Demonstrate the Power

HubSpot's Holistic B2B Transformation

HubSpot is a masterclass in integrated marketing for B2B marketers. In the fiercely competitive marketing automation industry, it didn't just focus on product features. Instead, it built a holistic system spanning education, community, software, and service.

Its strategy combined content marketing (backed by HubSpot Academy), community building (powered by user groups), thought leadership (fueled by research reports), and customer success (supported by robust onboarding). Every touchpoint reinforced its core message: marketing should be helpful, not interruptive.

The results speak volumes. HubSpot grew from a startup into a company with more than $2.6 billion in revenue in 2024. Its holistic strategy created competitive advantages that product features alone could not.

Starbucks' Omnichannel Excellence

Starbucks shows strategic brilliance in holistic marketing among B2C brands. Its mobile app isn't just a payment tool; it's the hub of a connected experience that covers loyalty rewards, personalized offers, mobile ordering, and community.

The integration is seamless. Mobile and in-store activity are connected. Email campaigns are timed to align with app notifications. Social media content changes with the seasonal menu. Even the design of its physical stores reinforces brand values around community and craft.

Their mobile play accounts for a growing share of the business: in the first quarter of fiscal 2019, Starbucks Rewards grew to 16.3 million active members in the U.S., up 14% year over year. Loyalty members who order through the app give Starbucks the data to personalize offers and drive repeat visits.

Salesforce's Customer Success Integration

Salesforce built its whole business model on holistic ideas. Its Trailhead training platform, vast partner ecosystem, annual Dreamforce event, and active customer community combine into an experience that goes well beyond conventional CRM software.

Each element reinforces the others. Trailhead educates users and builds brand loyalty at the same time. Ecosystem partners extend capabilities and advocacy. Dreamforce builds community and showcases innovation. Customer success teams help customers implement and expand.

This 360-degree approach played a key role in helping Salesforce deliver 20 percent growth or more a year for much of the past decade, before revenue growth slowed to single digits in fiscal 2025.


The Measurable Benefits Driving Adoption

1. Revenue Growth That Transforms Businesses

When we set up holistic marketing systems for clients, the financial effect is often both quick and significant. McKinsey data reports that companies combining brand and performance marketing across the funnel see marketing efficiency gains of up to 30%.

And that's just the beginning. McKinsey also reports incremental top-line growth of up to 10% without raising marketing budgets. How? By cutting out redundant work, reaching the target audience more precisely, and building synergy between channels, holistic marketing makes your budget go further.

Consistency affects revenue, too. Brands that present themselves consistently across all platforms tend to see stronger sales. Familiarity builds trust, improves recall, and creates the customer confidence that drives both initial sales and long-term loyalty.

2. Customer Retention Becomes Your Superpower

In an environment where customer acquisition costs have reportedly climbed by as much as 222% in the past eight years, according to a widely repeated industry estimate, retention isn't just important; it's make-or-break. Holistic marketing is very good at creating customers for life.

The statistics are compelling. A widely cited Aberdeen Group finding says companies with strong omnichannel engagement keep 89% of their current customers, versus 33% for companies with weak omnichannel engagement. That shouldn't be a surprise: when every touchpoint is cohesive and valuable, what reason does your customer have to look elsewhere?

We've found that clients who take a holistic approach significantly increase customer lifetime value. The secret isn't complicated: when marketing, sales, service, and product teams work from shared customer data and aligned goals, they create the experiences customers actually value.

3. Operational Efficiency That Scales

One of the most overlooked advantages of holistic marketing is operational efficiency. Breaking down silos and connecting systems helps companies avoid duplicated effort and refine their processes. McKinsey's performance branding research, linked here as an efficiency improvement of 30-40%, reports marketing efficiency gains of up to 30%.

Think about what happens in many traditional marketing departments. The email team does its own customer research for campaigns. The social media team does its own research. The content team commissions its own studies. Every team produces its own creative, with its own budget and its own success metrics. The waste is enormous.

Holistic marketing eliminates this redundancy. Shared customer data platforms become research resources everyone can use. Integrated design keeps brand assets consistent and production costs down. With unified analytics, you get a clear picture of what's working across all channels.


How We Implement Holistic Marketing for Maximum Success

Begin with Full Assessment and Plan

Every successful move toward holistic marketing starts with a realistic assessment. We audit current marketing processes with clients, looking for gaps, redundancies, and opportunities. This isn't about judgment; it's about setting a clear, agreed baseline for improvement.

This includes a technology stack assessment, process mapping, a team capability review, and customer journey documentation. We look at how information moves between systems, where it's handed off between teams, and which metrics drive decisions. Crucially, we identify quick wins that build momentum for bigger changes.

Planning follows assessment. We draw up phased implementation plans that balance ambition and feasibility. A typical holistic marketing transformation takes 6-12 months to implement fully, and we plan quick wins so clients start seeing value within the first 30-60 days.

Build the Technological Foundation

Modern marketing demands modern technology infrastructure. But success isn't about having the most tools; it's about having the right tools working together seamlessly.

The foundation is usually a Customer Data Platform (CDP) that brings together customer data from every touchpoint. We also connect marketing automation, CRM, analytics, and content management systems. The secret is easy data sharing between systems, which enables real-time personalization and coordinated campaigns.

It's telling that, by one figure attributed to Gartner, only 17% of marketers claim "high utilization" of their CDP. Gartner's broader martech research finds that overall martech utilization has dropped to 49%. Underuse is usually a result of poor implementation rather than a technical problem. We make sure clients not only have the right technology but can use it effectively.

Foster Organizational Alignment and Culture Change

Technology and processes matter, but people make a company succeed. The hardest, and most important, part of implementing holistic marketing is changing the organization itself. We help clients build cultures that reinforce integrated thinking and customer focus.

This starts with leadership alignment. When marketing programs fail for lack of support from the C-suite, the failure is usually preventable. We work with leaders to clarify the vision, allocate resources, and model a collaborative approach. Then we reinforce those intentions across the organization through training, communication, and aligned incentives.

Alignment between marketing and sales is linked with higher customer retention and higher win rates in the research HubSpot compiles. These aren't feel-good numbers; they tie directly to the bottom line.

Measure, Optimize, and Scale Continuously

Holistic marketing isn't a destination; it's an ongoing journey. We set up measurement frameworks that cover channel-specific metrics as well as overall business impact. This two-level approach keeps both strategy and tactics in focus.

Modern attribution modeling helps us understand how different touchpoints lead to conversion, and we go well beyond last-click attribution. Machine learning-derived multi-touch attribution models aim to estimate the real influence of each marketing investment across the whole customer journey, though their results still need careful interpretation.

The optimization process never stops. We just keep trying new things, honing targeting, tweaking messaging, testing new channels. What was successful yesterday may not be tomorrow, so we build in flexibility to every system and process.


Navigating Common Implementation Challenges

Breaking Down Stubborn Organizational Silos

Silos are the number one obstacle to holistic marketing. Teams exist for legitimate reasons: specialization builds expertise, clear divisions make management easier, and departmental focus can improve efficiency. But those gains are outweighed by the cost of fragmentation.

We tackle silos systematically. First, we create cross-functional teams for major initiatives so collaboration happens by design. We develop shared KPIs that tie teams to company goals rather than departmental ones. And we create spaces, in person and digital, where people naturally run into each other, because connections are often more valuable than procedures.

The transformation takes time. Expect 6-12 months before the culture starts to shift, and 18-24 months for broader transformation. But the results justify the effort. Clients report not only stronger marketing outcomes but also better employee satisfaction and more innovation.

Mastering Complex Attribution Across Channels

When prospects may encounter dozens of touchpoints before they buy, attribution gets complicated. How do you assign credit when a customer sees a Facebook ad, reads a blog post, opens an email, visits a store, and then buys online?

We build attribution models that cover both online and offline touchpoints, combining statistical analysis and machine learning to identify conversion paths and distribute credit. But we're also pragmatists: attribution will never be perfect, and it doesn't need to be if the insight is directionally correct and leads to better decisions.

Privacy laws compound the problem. As tracking signals shrink and privacy laws tighten, we work with clients on attribution solutions that respect user privacy while still measuring marketing performance.

Securing Adequate Resources and Investment

Holistic marketing takes investment in technology, people, and change. We often get pushback from executives who want to know the ROI of integration. Our answer combines education and evidence.

We share real examples of similar businesses that have seen strong returns from integrated marketing. We build detailed business cases with expected returns based on conservative assumptions. Above all, we structure implementations to deliver early wins that build confidence in the investment.

A comprehensive transformation usually needs some additional marketing investment at the start, but in many cases the efficiency gains pay it back. We help clients see it as infrastructure: an investment that provides a competitive advantage for years.


Future-Proofing Your Holistic Marketing Strategy

Embracing AI and Automation Thoughtfully

Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing marketing at remarkable speed. By 2025, the AI marketing market had already moved from experiment to routine: HubSpot's marketing statistics page, citing its 2026 research, reports that over 80% of marketers use AI for content creation. But success requires thoughtful integration, not wholesale adoption.

We help clients identify the AI use cases that actually move the needle. Predictive analytics helps anticipate customer needs. Natural language processing makes personalized content possible at scale. Computer vision can check visual content for brand compliance. Machine learning helps optimize campaign performance.

Human oversight and creativity remain essential. AI is very good at pattern recognition and optimization, but weak at emotional nuance and creative breakthroughs. We advocate collaboration between people and AI that plays to the strengths of each.

Preparing for the Privacy-First Future

Privacy regulations are fundamentally changing the marketing industry. The winners will be marketers who rethink their programs through a privacy-first lens, as browsers such as Safari and Firefox block third-party cookies by default and regulations such as GDPR and CCPA continue to tighten.

We advise clients on building sound first-party data strategies: value exchanges that give customers good reasons to share information with you. That requires transparent data practices that build trust, not loopholes that exploit what people don't know, along with technical infrastructure that protects privacy while still allowing personalization.

81 percent of consumers today say they must be able to trust a brand to do what is right, according to Edelman's 2019 Trust Barometer special report, and whether a brand will protect their data and privacy is part of that judgment. Privacy is more than a tick-box; it's a competitive advantage. Companies that get privacy right build deeper customer relationships and avoid the reputational damage of data breaches or misuse.

New Channel and Technology Adaptation

New channels and technologies seem to appear every day. Connected TV, voice commerce, augmented reality, and social commerce are all different ways to interact with customers. But chasing every shiny new channel wastes focus and resources.

We assist our clients in strategically assessing new channels. What channels are your customers really using? Which ones fit your brand experience? Which offer sustainable competitive advantage? Only after we have made all of these inquiries do we ever recommend adoption.

A full-funnel marketing model makes it easier to adopt new channels. With integrated data, unified messaging, and aligned teams, each new channel builds on the existing system instead of becoming a stand-alone effort.


Your Holistic Marketing Implementation Roadmap

Phase 1: Laying the Foundation (Months 1-2)

Start with assessment and planning. Be honest about where you are right now: which systems you use, how information flows, and where the major handoffs happen. Set clear targets for your holistic marketing transformation. What business objectives are you aiming for?

It's also important to secure executive sponsorship in this phase. C-suite backing often decides whether a transformation succeeds or fails. Build your business case carefully, showing expected returns against realistic investments. Find and deliver quick wins, and celebrate early value.

Build your transformation squad with members from all critical functions. This team will lead the charge, so select members that are strong in expertise and collaboration. Give them clear targets and the resources they need to achieve them.

Phase 2: Core Implementation (Months 3-6)

Begin with technology infrastructure. Implement a Customer Data Platform, or upgrade the one you have, to create a shared view of each customer. Connect essential systems so data flows between them. You don't need everything to be perfect at once; focus on the core integrations that let you run campaigns in unison.

Develop new processes that support integration. Start with campaign planning templates that account for every channel. Set meeting cadences so teams meet regularly. Document workflows so everyone understands handoffs and responsibilities.

Launch small pilot campaigns that test integrated principles. Choose campaigns with tangible goals and measurable results. Run these pilots thoroughly, learn, adjust, and build confidence in the new approach.

Phase 3: Optimization and Scale (Months 6-12)

Get the basics right, then refine. Evaluate pilot campaign performance to see what to improve and what to replicate. Iterate based on real experience. Scale what works and drop what doesn't.

Focus on training during this period. Everyone on the team should understand their role in the overall marketing machine. Deliver training that covers both the tactics of new tools and the strategic, collaborative thinking behind them.

Start taking the winning strategy and scaling it throughout the organization. What succeeded for one line of products can be of use to others. What worked in one geographic market can be replicated somewhere else. But be flexible, not every tactic works every time.

Phase 4: Continuous Evolution (Ongoing)

Holistic marketing is never really complete. Customer demands change, new tech is created, and competitive conditions change as well. Make continuous improvement part of your organization's DNA.

Set the schedule for reviewing your progress and opportunities. Develop innovation processes to experiment with new methods that won't disrupt your core business. More important though, retain that collaborative culture that enables holistic marketing to thrive.


Lessons From Our Many Years Doing This Stuff

Start Small But Think Big

Start with a few pilot projects that can show value quickly. Perhaps that means combining email and social media campaigns for one product category, or bringing sales and marketing teams together in a single region. Contained experiments like these build confidence and reveal problems before a full-scale rollout.

But keep the bigger picture in view from day one. Each small step should move you toward full integration. Record what you learn, recognize progress, and use early successes as a launchpad for broader transformation.

Invest in Your People First

Technology makes holistic marketing possible, but people make it work. Invest seriously in training, communication, and cultural change. Create opportunities for cross-functional collaboration. Recognize and reward integrated thinking. And remember: changing mindsets can take longer than rolling out new software.

We suggest investing 30% of transformation budgets in people-centred interventions. This may sound high, but it's the difference between transformative success and waste.

Measure Everything But Focus on the Right Thing

Modern marketing generates overwhelming data. The natural temptation is to track anything and everything. Resist this urge. Look at measurements tied to business goals. If customer retention is your goal, then focus on lifetime value instead of click-through rates.

Establish clear measurement hierarchies. Metrics by channel are crucial for optimization; business outcomes, however, inform strategy. Develop dashboards of tactical performance and strategic advances.

Build Flexibility Into Every System

Marketing changes rapidly. New channels emerge, consumer habits shift, and new technologies arrive. Build flexibility into every system and process. Choose technology with open APIs and broad integration capabilities. Design methods that can absorb new channels without major rework.

This flexible thinking also applies to strategy. Hold on to core principles, integration, customer focus, and measurement, while adjusting tactics as conditions change.


Holistic Marketing FAQs

What is the minimum investment needed to succeed with holistic marketing?

Holistic marketing can help businesses of any size, but implementation usually requires some investment beyond existing marketing budgets at the start. Those costs are often recovered through efficiency improvements. We've helped small businesses start with investments of around $50K a year (or less when the situation warrants), focusing on core integrations and process improvements before scaling.

How long will it take to see significant results?

Quick wins may arrive within 30-60 days, especially in areas like email engagement or customer acquisition costs. Significant revenue impact generally comes around the six-month mark, while full integration into your business takes 12-18 months. The secret is managing expectations while celebrating step-by-step progress.

Will holistic marketing be effective for B2B firms?

Absolutely. The payoff can be even higher for B2B companies with long buying cycles and complex buyer journeys. The HubSpot and Salesforce examples above both show the value of a well-rounded approach. In B2B, the details matter, which means account-based strategies and sales-marketing alignment are paramount.

What is the most common error companies make when applying holistic marketing?

The most common mistake is treating holistic marketing as an IT project instead of an organizational transformation. Organizations that invest only in technology, without attention to culture, processes, and alignment, often see meager results. Technology, people, and process must stay in balance.

What's the difference between holistic marketing and omni-channel marketing?

They're related but distinct. Omnichannel marketing means building a consistent customer experience across channels. Omnichannel is a subset of holistic marketing, which also includes internal marketing, social responsibility, and total business integration. Think of omnichannel as one ingredient in the larger holistic mix.

How should you measure the success of holistic marketing?

Track both channel-specific and holistic metrics. Channel metrics include engagement, conversion, and ROI by platform. Higher-level metrics include customer lifetime value, overall marketing efficiency, brand consistency scores, and customer satisfaction scores. The trick is tying channel performance directly to business results.

Is holistic marketing just another buzzword?

Definitely not. The core ideas of holistic marketing, connection, customer-centricity, and an integrated approach, are closely tied to business performance. Organizations in Demand Metric and Lucidpress's research estimated average revenue growth of 23% from consistent brand presentation, and Aberdeen Group research is widely cited for customer retention upticks of 89%, comparing customer retention of 89% at companies with strong omnichannel engagement with 33% at companies with weak engagement.


Related Terms


The Marketing Mix as Competitive Advantage for Holistic Marketing

In today's fragmented attention economy, integrated marketing isn't a luxury; it's a competitive necessity. Customers expect seamless experiences and consistency across channels, and they reward companies that deliver them.

Companies that practice holistic marketing don't just meet these expectations; they exceed them. By breaking down silos, integrating technologies, and aligning entire organizations around what matters to customers, they build experiences competitors can't easily replicate.

The financial case is clear: consistent brand presentation, stronger customer retention, and more efficient marketing spend all add up. But the strategic advantage matters even more. An integrated approach builds lasting competitive advantages: stronger customer orientation, more efficient operations, and greater flexibility in responding to change.

We've helped hundreds of companies make this transition at Arfadia. We've seen struggling businesses climb to the top of their markets. We've seen siloed marketing teams become strategic growth engines. Most of all, we've helped our clients build the kind of customer relationships that fuel long-term success.

The road to holistic marketing isn't always easy. It takes investment, commitment, and patience. But for businesses ready to embrace the transformation, the rewards can be substantial. In a world of rising customer expectations and growing competition, holistic marketing isn't just a nicer way to market; it's the most reliable way to build sustainable success.

Ready to move from scattered marketing to one integrated approach? The principles are clear, the benefits are measurable, and there's no time like the present. Your prospects are looking for the frictionless, connected experiences that holistic marketing provides. The question isn't whether to make your marketing holistic; it's how quickly you can get there.


References:

We use cookies

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyze traffic, and personalize content. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Cookie Settings
PT Arfadia Digital Indonesia

We use cookies to ensure the website runs optimally and to help us understand how you use our services. You can choose which categories to allow. Read our Privacy Policy.

Necessary Cookies Always Active

Required for basic website functionality. Cannot be disabled.

Analytics Cookies

Help us understand how visitors interact with the website. Data used anonymously.

Marketing Cookies

Used to display relevant ads and measure campaign effectiveness.

Functional Cookies

Enables live chat, social media integrations, and language preferences.

Preferences saved